
So, you ask, can Tchaikowskiana really be considered an example of easy listening? And since when is Tchaikovsky spelled "Tchaikowsky"?
These are good questions, and they deserve to be answered. The answer to question #2, of course, is that "Tchaikowsky" is the old-fashioned American spelling. You see it all over sheet music and records. And I hate it when people write their name over all things. (Sound of tin cans crashing.)
That didn't quite work. But we'll pretend it did and just move on....
Question #1--can this fantasia on T. themes be considered vintage easy listening? Yes, I think so. After all my years of studying the pop instrumental genre, I'm still inclined to think that easy listening (as we know and love it) evolved directly from the light/semi-/middle-brow orchestral music of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Proving it is the hard part, of course. Sure, I have any number of examples that would seem to support my notion, but organizing data around a thesis--as common as the practice may be--isn't valid scholarship. Only preponderance of historical evidence can prove a hypothesis like mine, especially given its very general nature. And I don't have close to all the data I need. All I can say at this point is that the suggestion doesn't contradict the data I've collected. Which is a lot more than nothing, to be sure.
I'll bet you didn't know how academic this blog is. Now you do. For more than 20 years, I've been studying this branch of pop music--and you can see what it's done to my once fine mind. Don't follow my tragic example.
But DO give a listen to these excellent, superb, compelling, and not at all shabby easy listening gems from the days when things were cheaper and highway traffic was lighter. The fun starts with three Vincent Youmans selections played (and, presumably, arranged) by Russ Case, who provided some superb arrangements for both Perry Como and Andre Kostelanetz. (Around this blog, that's a major endorsement.) I rescued these from a 45 EP, and I'm guessing the original recording date to be in the 1945-48 range. In all probability, it originated as a 78 set. In time, it'll show up on some list, or in a thrift, or a 1940s RCA catalog. I have faith.
Next up, two 1952 sides by Mitch Miller, both superbly arranged and superbly easing. As easy should be. The first number is by Jimmy Carroll, who arranged for Columbia and the Bell label, and who gave us the Sing Along with Mitch sound. (So there.) Harpsichord by Buddy Weed and Stan (Come On-a My House) Freeman, respectively. I love the muted chorus on the first--were they singing from another room, possibly? Great effect. Ripped from a white label DJ 78.
Tchaikowskiana, arranged by Herman Hand for Paul Whiteman, is a fantasia on T. themes, and is very well done, considering how hokey it could have turned out. Adapting famous melodies and shaping them into a medley is a tradition (or, some snobs would say, a crime) that continues to this day. What some might dub a weird relic from 1928, I call pop music as usual.
Easy listening as we know and love it existed in full by 1940. Proof: Andre Kostelanetz' Highlights from Porgy and Bess, a Gershwin medley arranged by Nathan Van Cleave (who later penned music for The Twilight Zone). My 78 gets a little noisy by the end of Side 2, but that can happen. Old records, old needles, the forces of time. They all work together to make audio restoration a more challenging and interesting task. (Damn shellac discs!) Oops. I don't know who said that. It wasn't me.
Click here to reach the music: Easy Listening Blowout, Part 2
PLAYLIST
TEA FOR TWO(Caesar-Youmans)--Russ Case Orch. and Chorus.
HALLELUJAH (Robin-Grey-Youmans)--Russ Case Orch. and Chorus.
GREAT DAY (Caesar-Youmans)--Russ Case Orch. and Chorus.
JUST DREAMING (J. Carroll)--Mitch Miller Orch., Buddy Weed, harpsichord, 1952.
WITHOUT MY LOVER (BOLERO GAUCHO)--Mitch Miller Orch., Stan Freeman, harp., 1952.
TCHAIKOWSKIANIA (Arr: Herman Hand)--Paul Whiteman Orch., 1928. From 12" 78.
HIGHLIGHTS FROM PORGY AND BESS (Arr: Nathan Van Cleave)--Andre Kostelanetz, 1940.
Lee
