

And you'll be glad he did. It's almost putting it lightly to say that Andre had quite a way with light music. I've always considered his 1942 recording of the Grand Canyon Suite to be on a par with Eugene Ormandy's 1958 version--they are, by far, the two best renditions of the post-Paul-Whiteman score (my apologies to Toscanini).
We'll be hearing Kosty's 1942 version straight from a 99-cent thrift copy of Columbia CL 716 (top), which was at least the label's second long-playing edition of the performance, which had originated as a 12-inch 78 set (found all over eBay). (And not to be confused with Andre's 1961 recording, which included a Johnny Cash narrative called A Day in the Grand Canyon!) It's hard to decide which is more astonishing--the quality of the original 1942 recording or the brilliance of Columbia's remastering. All I did was remove a few clicks and level the digital volume.
Kostelanetz' 1955 recording of the same year's Hudson River Suite is the best of the piece's three versions--we'll be hearing a rip from thrifted vinyl (what else?). I don't remember whether it was Stereo Review or High Fidelity, but one of the two magazines gave the suite a snide review, describing it as "of interest mainly for its special sound effects." Which, we have to say, are extremely well-done. At any rate, Classical critics of the time were angry over the fact that the average record buyer had no use for Honegger or Bartok or Piston, so they took it out on any and all examples of light music that came their way to review, save for the songs of Leroy Anderson. If it was popular, it had to be horrible--so went their reasoning. And you thought that idea originated with campus record store clerks (and/or NPR)! Well, you would be wrong. We're all wrong some of the time. (And somewhat wrong all of the time.)
To the Grofe: Grand Canyon Suite--Andre Kostelanetz, 1942. Hudson River Suite--Andre Kostelanetz, 1955.
PLAYLISTS
Grand Canyon Suite (Ferde Grofe, 1931)--Andre Kostelanetz and His Orch., 1942.
Sunrise
The Painted Desert
On the Trail
Sunset
Cloudburst
Hudson River Suite (Ferde Grofe, 1955)--Andre Kostelanetz and His Orch., 1955.
The River
Henry Hudson
Rip Van Winkle
Albany Night Boat
New York
Lee




