I refer to the Big Ten Inch Record song by Fred Weismantel, which was recorded in 1952 by Bull Moose Jackson, and not the excellent blog by that title, though the latter is always worth checking out.
It seems that Fred wrote songs (and, according to a Youtube blurb, also produced sessions) for the Columbia quartet The Four Voices. The best of that bunch, the superb Lovely One, was a top 40 hit in 1956 and is included in today's playlist along with two others written by Weismantel--the memorable Angel of Love and the rather contrived, but still interesting, Sidewalk Bop.
Lovely One is new to me and a total delight to discover (sorry about the so-so sound--I dubbed it from a VG- copy). As a rock and roll production and arrangement, it's the equal of Devil or Angel or Oh What a Nite, and it belies the stereotype of stiff, unsoulful white cover versions in that 1) it's anything but stilted and 2) it wasn't, to the best of my knowledge, a cover. Our fourth track, by the Four Coins, is definitely a cover--and an excellent one.
Now, Rock History is weird regarding... well, just about everything, but especially in regard to white covers of black R&B hits. The practice is seen as a crime to the original titles and artists, and there's very good reason to see them as such--they took sales away from same and often (but by no means always) lacked the freshness and drive of the copied performances.
Yet, somehow, when Elvis came along and covered black material, or when Buddy Holly swiped from Bo Diddley, or when, years later, British youth made like Howlin' Wolf, John Lee Hooker, and Muddy Waters--suddenly, "covers" were a good thing. An original, white thing, even. Theft ceased to be theft, because, apparently, when you do a really, really good job at swiping something, it's no longer an instance of swiping.
Anyway, we continue with two 1954 r&r-style hits by the Four Coins (at least one--I Love You Madly--being a cover) and a 1955 title in the same vein, PLUS the Four Lads, in 1955, covering Pledging My Love. Columbia's plan was masterful, not to mention original--avoiding rock and roll by recording it.
We keep the "doo wop" motif going with the Metrotones' 1955 Columbia disc, Tonight, which steals La Paloma for its melody. And the Four Voices return for the elaborate (but rocking) Geronimo, which I added to fill out the list to ten tracks. And because it's a great side, its un-p.c. moments notwithstanding.
To the music: Rock Along with Mitch, Part 5 (Mitch, Part 15)
PLAYLIST
LOVELY ONE (Fred Weismantel)--The Four Voices w. Ray Conniff, 1956.
ANGEL OF LOVE (F. Weismantel)--The Four Voices w. Ray Conniff, 1957.
SIDEWALK BOP (F. Weismantel)--The Four Voices w. Ray Conniff, 1957.
STORY UNTOLD--The Four Coins w. Don Costa Orch., 1955.
I LOVE YOU MADLY (C. Jones)--The Four Coins, 1954.
MAYBE (Croswell)--The Four Coins, 1954.
MY ANXIOUS HEART (Sanford--O. Jones)--The Four Coins, 1955.
PLEDGING MY LOVE (FOREVER MY DARLING)--The Four Lads, 1955.
TONIGHT (Wolfson-White-Cassin)--The Metrotones w. Sid Bass Orch., 1955.
GERONIMO (Ebb-Klein-Coleman)--The Four Voices w. Ray Conniff, 1956.
Lee

