Steven Foster classics in swing time: Bill St. Clair and the Eddie Maynard Orchestra beautifully manage this goal. It helps when the songs are terrific, the vocalist is excellent, and the arrangements spot on. This LP is a wonderful surprise--way above the norm for Parade.
However, as we congratulate Bill St. Clair and the Eddie Maynard Orch., I think it's fair to ask... do or did either of those persons exist? Under those names, I mean?
Let's look at the evidence: This LP also showed up on Spinorama, Palace, Coronet, and Riviera. Here, the orchestra is credited to Eddie Maynard, but elsewhere it's assigned to Fontanna, Mark Andrews, David Bruce, and... artist-unknown. And, on Coronet, Bill becomes Dick Neilson. The Fontanna version (on Palace), gives no vocal credit at all, though at least it's in stereo. And had I known it was the same album, I'd have gone for it (because of the stereo), but the Parade monaural audio is nice enough--after I fixed it up, that is.
Bill, or Dick, or whomever, has a marvelous voice, and the Stephen-Foster-in-Swing-Time theme is beautifully managed, but we really have no reason to believe this singer is, in factual reality, named Bill St. Clair. In fact, at my fake-hits YT channel, I have a Bill St. "Claire" on Big 4 Hits singing "Shake Rattle and Roll," and it doesn't sound like the same guy. As for Eddie Maynard, he was a name-drop bandleader at SPC, Spinorama, and Parade. A fill-in-the-credit bandleader.
To be fair , Bill and Eddie ("Bill and Eddie"?) also put out an LP on Promenade called Let's Be Frank, on which Bill (or whoever he is) does a decent job imitating Frank Sinatra. This might compel us to believe that Bill St. Clair was the singer's real name, but there's the problem of the many different credits for these Stephen Foster tracks. And there's the problem that Bill seems to have done nothing outside of the rack-jobber realm. Nobody said rack-jobber detective work was easy...
Anyway, according to the liner notes, "This is a great unique album and will provide many hours of listening enjoyment." (If put it on repeat play, I guess...) "Bill has a tremendously great voice," the notes continue, and Bill is a singer "from the Boston area who has his own TV and radio shows." Except, I can find no online confirmation of same, and Google's AI can't, either. No TV or radio shows on file for one Bill St. Clair. Still, this is a superior budget-album experience--fine vocalist, spot-on arrangements, and great American tunes. Hats off to Bill, Dick, Fontanna, Artist Unknown, and everyone else involved.
DOWNLOAD: Bill St. Clair Swings Stephen Foster Favorites.zip FLAC
Beautiful Dreamer
I Dream of Jeannie with the Light Brown Hair
Nellie Bly
Old Dog Trey
Ring Ring de Banjo
Old Folks at Home
My Old Kentucky Home
Gentle Annie
Oh Susannah
Hard Times
Come Where My Love Lies Dreaming
Camptown Races
Lee








