Well, I jut had a false memory in which I had already put up an album from this series--but it looks like I didn't. Rather, I was recalling
this post, in which LPs are similarly strewn across the carpet--except the cover shows three gals having a slumber party. That was an RCA Camden special--this is Hollywood Records, which I'm always confusing with Broadway. And we can imagine the cover girl saying, "Give me that Frankie disc--I hate fake hits!" I don't know what's playing on the vintage 45 rpm player--it's an EP, is all I can see. On the floor, there appears to be... let's see... Eddie Fisher, Frank Sinatra, Eddie again, Nat King Cole, Tennessee Ernie Ford (?), and Arthur Murray. There are at least two other jackets, but they're obscured. So, why would Hollywood Records be plugging the major labels? To give the buyer the impression that Hollywood was a major label? Who'd be that out of it?
The Nation's 12 Big Hit Recordings--that sounds very official, no? As named by the Nation's Twelve Big Hits Association of Cheapsville, Ohio, probably. The exact same over art was used for all of the LPs in this series, as far as I know--I have four others, and it's same guy and gal and 45 rpm player. There was probably a standard catalog number. This has a "C" to distinguish it from, say, A or B. The weird thing with this one: I had just bought a hammered copy of this from eBay, because I saw I didn't have these selections in my
12 Big Hit Recordings stash. The dealer graded it at VG-, which it was, more or less (G+/VG-; who can say?), and so I had to do a lot of sonic surgery to get a good file. Then, right after I'd completed the rip, a much better copy showed up at one of the local Goodwills, along with five other fake-hit LPs. I was stunned, because these things hardly ever show up at the thrifts anymore, but not too stunned to grab them all and shell out my ones. (Or was it two fives? Or a ten?) Next trip to the same thrift, there were two or three more fake-hit comps. Then... nothing more. So far.
That was supposed to be an interesting account, but I don't think it quite made it. Anyway, excellent condition, (this one--not the eBay purchase), but the usual cheap pressing--therefore, some hiss to reckon with. And we're in the 1957/58 realm, a point at which the cheap labels were trading off tracks like crazy--which is to say, most or all of these also came out on Synthetic Plastics Co. and Tops singles and LPs, because I've heard several of these about a million times, to date--
At the Hop,
Kisses Sweeter Than Wine (which I'm starting to hate),
Jailhouse Rock, and
Silhouettes. I'll have to do some fast side-by-side comparing, and then I'll get back. Unless I get hopelessly lost in the Media Room jungle.
Nope, here I am. So, I'm playing one of my
12 Top Hits on Tops Records, and
April Love is the same as here (except for some Tops reverb).
At the Hop--same.
Peggy Sue--same (with
way more reverb on Tops).
Kisses--ditto.
Great Balls of Fire--yup.
Jailhouse Rock--yup, again. I'm listening to the topside LP in
this post, by the way. Much duplication, though the Tops label reverb is kind of annoying next to the undoctored sound here. So, even though a number of these tracks are blog repeats, you're getting purer audio with this rip. And all of the above (save for
Kisses) are superior fakes, reverb or no. Meanwhile, I don't recall previously encountering fakes (or non-fakes) of
Put a Light in the Window and
My Special Angel. Neither one makes my day, though I'm betting the Four Lads did a much better job on the former.
At this point in fake-hits history (late 1950s), SPC (Promenade, Prom, etc.) was putting out the same versions as Tops (and, evidently, Hollywood), so some kind of consolidation was happening. A single outfit providing the masters, maybe. Yet, Broadway (and its sublabel, Value Hit Parade) was still putting out its own fakes. That changed around 1960 or 1961. Broadway had been absorbed. Into what, or by whom, I don't know.
This cover scan is from my eBay copy, which was torn on the "LPH-100-C" part, so I grafted that portion from my Goodwill copy. Now you know.
DOWNLOAD--The Nation's 12 Big Hit Recordings
Lee